How can it hurt?? I don't know how. I don't know if.
I do know there's something about the idea of screwing with the bedrock, and with the deep water table, that scares the living daylights out of me. Those are big things for our small minds and narrow fields of vision (that seem to get even smaller and narrower when our comforts and dollar signs are involved).
I can also see through my cousin's eyes. He's a driller. Fracking means work. His father owns the mineral rights to their land. Fracking means money. This in a place where McDonald's can be considered a "good job."
What scares me the most?? In WV and southeast PA, from what I hear, out-of-state companies bring in out-of-state equipment and out-of-state crews to extract the resources and take the profits-- guess where???-- out of state. This happened when the coal industry moved in circa 100 years ago; it resulted in environmental degradation and economic depression. "Undercapitalization," they call it. Robbery is more like it. And we're going to let it happen again??
Royalties to the property owner for mineral rights are, I'm told, running around twelve and a half percent.
I'd howl about stopping fracking if I had the heart. I don't. People demand money, people demand their comforts (and they want them cheap). Natural gas generation is just another way of forstalling the inevitable collapse of a fossil-fuel economy...
...but then again, the only thing that isn't delaying the inevitable in this world is suicide.
Still-- Call me a socialist, but shouldn't the resources belong to the people who live there, or at least to the states themselves?? Shouldn't those people-- or at least state governments-- decide if they're going to be used and how?? Shouldn't the money stay where the resources came from??