I'm irritated you tried to turn this into a debate instead of catching my meaning.
Do you think just you and I are having a disagreement here alone?
I really don't care if you store your water in old battery acid drums. People do stupid stuff all the time. I could care less about what you actually do at your home.
But you are talking to not only those in this thread, but every lurker and every person who will read this later. Their takeaway from your commentary is that as long as they think it is food grade then it is a good idea to store water in it. So they answer a craigslist ad or meet some guy who says he can get a great deal on barrels for them who swears they are food grade. Or they find a barrel that has something as benign as dish soap in it and figures that is likely fine to use. And then they poison themselves because they saw others HERE ON SB being casual about the matter.
When you talk here about what you do at home that is inherently dangerous then you put others at risk, because people come here to get good answers.
The correct answer always on this forum is that food grade barrels always have the food label on them or they are not food grade. To say absolutely anything else gives the novice reader the impression that rule is not hard and fast.
So feel happy you won the debate. Now how will you feel when some n00b to prepping comes here to learn and takes your casual stance because they they don't know any better and assumes you know what you are talking about......and gets themselves poisoned?
Glad to see you've tried to become a fine upstanding member of this prepper community.
By definition this was a debate. I didn't turn it into a debate, it was a debate. Obviously this was not between just you and I. The point of an open forum is that anyone can chime in, they just chose not to.
It is awesome that you care so little for me, but the lurkers that come on here need to be cared for. That is just cruel. Just having fun, I know what you mean. You are assuming a lot about the intelligence of the community in your post. It is not fair to assume what people will think. Now with assumptions out of the way, I don't think them to be food grade, I know them to be food grade. I will state this one more time for you, since I do not know for certain what was in them before I bought them, I am using them for grey water. You said yourself, food grade barrels are made differently then other barrels, so knowing exactly where these barrels come from and the regulations that the factory has in place, tells me that these barrels had to be made to the standard of a food grade barrel. So no they are not food grade barrels, they are barrels made out of food grade plastics. I learned my lesson there. I might be being casual on the issue but who are you to tell me that I must not use these barrels for grey water because they are not food grade.
It would be the readers own fault for not doing their own research. By what seems to be your reasoning throughout this post, if anything is posted on this website then others will take it to be fact. Lets make sure from here on out no one expresses any opinion on SB, lest someone makes a bad decision based on our opinions. No one try anything or do anything that could be a danger to anyone that reads on this website. No trying to can your own food, or trying food that are out of date. No building your own bunkers. No loading up a BOB and practicing with it (someone might break an ankle). No anything that could endanger others that read what you post. That is basically how parts of your post reads. I know that is not your intention but we have to be mindful of what we post.
I do not feel as though I won this argument, I conceded to you and I learned to not call a food grade barrel without a content label a food grade barrel. You have won that debate. They are not food grade barrels, they are barrels made out of food grade plastics.
I wouldn't feel bad about anything, they made choices as an adult. They read my argument and they read yours. It is up to them to make their own informed decision. Let me put it this way, If I skydive and tell everyone how much fun it was, and then they go jump out of a plane with a parachute and die is it my fault? Should I feel bad? No. Now if I pressured that person to go skydiving, and just kept insisting that they needed to do it, then they died, that is a different story.
In closing, I posted my stance, you posted yours, it is up them them as adults to do their own research and make their own decisions, but with your rational that makes me a disreputable member of this community. I don't know your rational behind that statement but you are entitled to it.
___________________________________
I can argue my point in paragraph form if that would make it easier for you.
Line by line itemization gives the reader a reference point for the argument. It allows the reader to not have to go back and reference the previous post for every statement that was made on my behalf. It also allows the poster (a.k.a me) a reference point to make their arguments. Sorry it is a hold over from other forums I am apart of where it is the norm to do so. I also do realize that within this forum it does actually reference the previous posts under the dialog box it is just awkward for me since I am not used to it.
Yes I did split hairs but I did admit that I did it in jest. :thumb: