Congratulations!
Since you are looking for opinions I will put in my thoughts. I had written a pretty long response in the 'Quick Reply' box but it disappeared so I'll keep this short.
In short: Vaccinate
#1 - Might have issues going to public school without them
#2 - Vaccines reduce the risk of serious illness during a very susceptible period of your child's life. As already mentioned, little kiddo immune systems are not as strong as an adults (Breast Feed to get some passive immunity! - Thanks Mom!).
Common bacteria like hemophilus influenza (Hib) and pneumococcus (PCV) cause cause life threatening infections in young children (less than 1 year old). I mention common, because unlike other disease vaccinated for, these two bugs are all over the place. Adults generally shake this off no problem (like yourself not needing to see a doc). But in a kiddo, these infections can cause death. Hib can cause epiglottitis. Epiglottitis is inflammation of the upper airway - in adults generally just a sore throat - in kids it means such violent inflammation that there airway swells closed. I saw it once in an unvaccinated 2 year old, she died because no one could secure an airway. Hib and Pneumococcus can cause sepsis and meningitis in the little kiddos, again because their immune systems suck. Meningitis can mean permanent disability (if diagnosed and treated) or death due to overwhelming infection. These two bugs are scary. They are common, adults have them, older kids might get them, little kids can die with them.
Polio, measles, mumps, rubella. All uncommon. You may say "so what". But they are uncommon in the typical US population because of Vaccines! Other parts of the world are not as fortunate. We all know the image of the iron lung, Polio is bad. Its still out there, and it is still in the US, but preventable by a few shots. MMR can cause life threatening brain infections in the unvaccinated. Again, used to be commonly seen in little kids (I call them 'snotbags' for a reason), but herd immunity has done wonders. Even worse, if little unvaccinated Johnny comes home from school and rubs some MMR virus on pregnant Mommy (who was vaccinated), the unborn child is at risk for birth defects...
#3 - Opposition sites the Autism argument, which I do not find to be reasonable or scientifically sound.
Just some background. If you couldn't tell, I'm an ER doc. I'm also Uncle to an amazing kid who happens to be on the Autism spectrum, and married to a beautiful wife who teaches special education and children with autism.
Vaccines prevent disease, its a fact (Smallpox, Polio, Pneumococcus, Hib, MMR - all down because of vaccines), no more is needed to be said there.
There is no scientific data that shows that vaccines cause Autism. There are some articles (as in scientific, peer-reviewed journal articles) published that suggested it, but the science is flawed and the conclusions are overstated in my opinion. This notion has been sensationalized in the media and internet, but has no grounding other than opinion and anecdote. Association does not mean causation. Going by a police lock-up on St. Patty's day and seeing that being in cuffs is associated with wearing a green shirt, does not mean that if I wear green I'm gonna be a criminal.
Autism is much more common today. Many who would not have been diagnosed even 15 years ago will be diagnosed today partly because it is more publicly known.
Another concern is that your child might get the disease from the vaccine. People always seem to mention the "live" vaccines. Unless you are immunocompromised "live" vaccines will not be an issue. Your kid might get the sniffles and a fever afterwords, that just means its working (an immune response has been triggered and your kids immune system is developing antibodies and memory).
I would vaccinate. In my mind the risk of serious infection that is life threatening to my child far outweighs the risk that is based on opinion and not science that vaccines may cause autism or some other... who knows what the next thing will be....
Just some things to add after reading other posts:
Amish aren't vaccinated and don't get autism - they also don't seek routine medical care as often and family members aren't as well informed on autism because they don't read the internet or see the sensationalized stores in the media - if they do have autism they are MUCH less likely to be diagnosed...
The medical industry only cares about money and NOT the well being of its 'customers.' Maybe some truth in regard that money drives everything. But with that logic you may as well remove the antibiotic stocks from your preps...