Survivalist Forum banner

Health care rant

11K views 190 replies 54 participants last post by  tblount  
#1 ·
Took my 2 kids in for a strep test the other day. Pay my $50 copay ($25 each) they don't even see the doctor, just a pa. Get a bill today for $148 for each kid. $40 for each test and $133 for office visit each..How on earth can people afford to even seek medical treatment.??? Thanks for the rant....
 
#2 ·
I get migraine headaches. I try never to run out of migraine medication, but one time last year I did run out because my pharmacy could not find a source for the medication for a period of three weeks or so.

After suffering for two days with a really bad migraine, I went to the emergency room. I was there for about an hour and a half. I was given an injection of the same stuff I normally get at the pharmacy.

A month or so later I received paperwork from my insurance company - an accounting of the charges for the visit to the emergency room. The total charge was - wait for it - $2100.

How outrageous is that?

Fortunately, my insurance plan kicked in $2000, and I had to pay only $100.

But I'm just saying...
 
#35 ·
migraine

I get migraine headaches. I try never to run out of migraine medication, but one time last year I did run out because my pharmacy could not find a source for the medication for a period of three weeks or so.

After suffering for two days with a really bad migraine, I went to the emergency room. I was there for about an hour and a half. I was given an injection of the same stuff I normally get at the pharmacy.

A month or so later I received paperwork from my insurance company - an accounting of the charges for the visit to the emergency room. The total charge was - wait for it - $2100.

How outrageous is that?



Fortunately, my insurance plan kicked in $2000, and I had to pay only $100.

But I'm just saying...
Just FYI, I cured my migraines accidentally. Feverfew herb. The pain doc was plying me with more and more drugs and no real results. I googled for something natural and found feverfew. I am not sure how long I took it, maybe 6 months, and I wasn't having the headaches, so tapered off it. They never returned. When looking this up for someone, I read that 25% of feverfew users are cured.
I am NEVER one of the lucky 25%!!!!!
 
#6 ·
Took my 2 kids in for a strep test the other day. Pay my $50 copay ($25 each) they don't even see the doctor, just a pa. Get a bill today for $148 for each kid. $40 for each test and $133 for office visit each..
Sounds about right. I'm curious what you think would be a fair amount. Not a "good deal", but a fair price that helps pay the high costs of running a clinic (including paying a doctor to be around in case you need them).

On the bright side, costly medical care encourages everyone to take better care of themselves. Many, if not most, medical issues nowadays are "lifestyle related" (diet, exercise, etc).

Hope your kids are doing better..
 
#38 ·
Exactly, I have been an ER nurse for nearly 20 years. One thing I can tell you is more than 50% of the people who come in do not have insurance, do not pay their bills, and think that they should be taken care of since they refuse to care for themselves.
They have Iphones, name brand smokes, fancy clothes, nice cars, etc etc. Funny part is they say they can't afford health care at any level.
 
#8 ·
Sad thing is, there are too many of us that remember when medical insurance was good...
Our first two children, the entire copay - birth, hospitalization, everything - was fifty dollars.
Fifty.
Seriously, that's all we paid. I spent more than that for flowers for my wife.
And this wasn't decades ago, I'm talking about 1999 and 2000 here.
Our last child (2009), it was over 1800 out of pocket... That's a 3,600 percent rise, if you're keeping score.

But, as the gov gets more involved, costs go up and efficiency decreases.

Just vote for Bernie though, it'll all be "free..." If by free, you mean really really bad, capitated, rationed, and generally inaccessible.

The worst thing that ever happened was the creation of middle men between doctors and patients.
Look at the places where there aren't those middle men. Say, cosmetic surgery, or Lasix.
What's happened there? Prices have come down, access has increased, and there is competition for your business.
Competition, drives innovation. And it benefits the consumer.

Putting anything in between, decreases responsiveness and creates customer frustration. Notice that healthcare is the only place where this happens in our economy. And be mindful of it's effect.
Government involvement, kills.
Period.
 
#15 ·
But, as the gov gets more involved, costs go up and efficiency decreases.
Costs have been going up for a long time, even before Obama.

Just vote for Bernie though, it'll all be "free..." If by free, you mean really really bad, capitated, rationed, and generally inaccessible.

The worst thing that ever happened was the creation of middle men between doctors and patients.
Yep, I hate the fact that I have to beg an insurance adjuster to get an MRI.
Look at the places where there aren't those middle men. Say, cosmetic surgery, or Lasix LASIK, Lasix is a diuretic :thumb:.
What's happened there? Prices have come down, access has increased, and there is competition for your business.
Competition, drives innovation. And it benefits the consumer.

Putting anything in between, decreases responsiveness and creates customer frustration. Notice that healthcare is the only place where this happens in our economy. And be mindful of it's effect.
Government involvement, kills.
Period.
Reasons healthcare so expensive

1. Obama care
2. we're all paying for the millions of uninsured illegals . Probably around 30 - 50 million of them .
3. Big drug companies are ripping us off . Making HUGE $$$
4. insurance companies making HUGE $$$
5. malpractice lawsuits / lawyers
6. IN general - greed , fraud , waste , abuse , government interference
don't forget out of control hospitals who charge $25 for an aspirin, if they even tell you at all

reason healthcare is so expensive is the over-utilization of expensive methods of treatment. go to the er for a cold, 95 year old having a cardiac catheterization and stents, demented 80 year old getting dialysis. the list goes on , the pts have a right to demand all the care they want when they want it even if it makes no sense to do it, if doctors refuse the lawyers show up, just put 90 year old vegetated grandma in the icu and make sure she gets the most aggressive care she can have, spend 10,000 a day on her because the family does not want to make a decision. seen this play out hundreds of times. that's where your money goes.
yep, but if you even suggest holding off on the heroics, you'll have Sarah Palin calling it a Death Panel :xeye:
 
#9 ·
Medicare pays $0.42 for every dollar of medical cost in a hospital.

Guess who picks up the remaining 58% of the bill - anyone with insurance.

This doesn't include those that are treated that don't even have socialized medicine through medicare... let alone medicaid.

If you have insurance, the bills for most of the patients around you are being paid - By you.

Redistribution sucks when you are the one stuck with the bill.
 
#17 ·
actually, this isnt quite correct. medicare pays UP TO 80 percent for the patient. even with medicare the patient is always on the hook for the 20% of the bill unless they pay for either a supplement/medigap policy, have medicaid as their secondary policy, or have a medicare advantage policy which has thousands of dollars as a deductible.
 
#10 ·
Medicare sets a price on every procedure, pays a percentage, and your co insurance is on the hook for the rest of their price. The provider does not get 100% of what they charge.

Of my $3500 bill at er when I had a seizure, medicare determined it was going to pay $575, they paid 80% of that, I owed only the 20% of the balance, about $120. NOT $3000.

On the d.o.b. there is paid to provider, and patient amount. I've never had to pay over the patient amount. And the secondary pays that...

If a provider demands full payment from you after accepting medicare, it's felony fraud.
 
#12 ·
Reasons healthcare so expensive

1. Obama care
2. we're all paying for the millions of uninsured illegals . Probably around 30 - 50 million of them .
3. Big drug companies are ripping us off . Making HUGE $$$
4. insurance companies making HUGE $$$
5. malpractice lawsuits / lawyers
6. IN general - greed , fraud , waste , abuse , government interference
 
#13 ·
reason healthcare is so expensive is the over-utilization of expensive methods of treatment. go to the er for a cold, 95 year old having a cardiac catheterization and stents, demented 80 year old getting dialysis. the list goes on , the pts have a right to demand all the care they want when they want it even if it makes no sense to do it, if doctors refuse the lawyers show up, just put 90 year old vegetated grandma in the icu and make sure she gets the most aggressive care she can have, spend 10,000 a day on her because the family does not want to make a decision. seen this play out hundreds of times. that's where your money goes.
 
#18 ·
In addition to all the above reasons, a major healthcare cost driver is Big Pharma direct to consumer advertising. This has taken over from R&D as many companies' greatest expense since the mid 90s when the law allowed it.

Drug and other treatment modality advertising lends to the technological emperative that physicians write for the latest most expensive medication or diagnostic exam even when a less expensive alternative is available.

Drug companies have the highest profit margin of the other health care industries which drive up costs, but that is a different topic.
 
#20 ·
On the other hand, on occasion, sometimes things just work out. I had gall bladder surgery a few weeks ago and this week went for my first follow up.

docs office told me that any follow up for 90 days is included with my surgical cost--already paid for a grand total of $150.00 dollars to the surgeon--so no more money out of pocket to him.
 
#21 ·
I don't have insurance. I went through the Obama care process and they simply dumped me to a choice of two insurance companies charging $1000 a month and not kicking in till I paid $6,700 a year deductible. I can't pay $19,000 a year while making less than $5,000. I went to the emergency room a while back with elevated blood pressure and now have a bill for almost $1,000 for an xray and 3 blood test.

Fortunately there a few federally funded clinics for the indignant.

It seems there are several problems...

1. Greed - pay for the pills or die. A monopolistic situation.
2. Insurance companies taking money OUT of the health care system without ever actually treating anyone.
3. Frivolous law suits forcing Doctors to order every test available just to cover their butts.

The government actually prevents competition in this industry in their attempt to eliminate a few quacks.
 
#30 ·
I can't pay $19,000 a year while making less than $5,000. I went to the emergency room a while back with elevated blood pressure and now have a bill for almost $1,000 for an xray and 3 blood test.


3. Frivolous law suits forcing Doctors to order every test available just to cover their butts.
I don't understand - if you make so little, I would think you'd get a full subsidy.

#3 - I completely agree.

Another thing I don't understand (and this isn't aimed just at you) is why more people don't utilize urgent care. I'd have to be fearing death (or serious harm) to go to an emergency room. Is it just that these are not located everywhere?
 
#22 ·
Shoot you got it lucky. Obamacare just about killed me. I currently have a PICC line in my arm undergoing 6 weeks of antibiotic treatments to hopefully prevent a surgery now. I have a 3 month waiting period for a doctor, any doctor, 1st available appointment.

Spent a week in the hospital. My deductibles have never been higher. Financially I'm toast. Thank you Obamacare.
 
#23 ·
Healthcare Costs vs Obamacare

This is the first year for me to file a tax return after having received Obamacare for one year. The government is charging a tax for the subsidy monies given to make the insurance "affordable". I'm retired, on SS, and the subsidy "assistance" I qualify for which makes the insurance affordable is a blessing but to tax those monies in the aftermath ?

I now understand why folks are forgoing the insurance and simply paying the $250 fine for not having Obamacare.

Pre-Obamacare, folks went to the emergency room if they couldn't afford healthcare insurance. The hospitals did their best to collect what they could from those patients, in a number of cases resorting to "writing off" the charges because the patient couldn't/wouldn't pay. That drove up the cost of hospital healthcare. Those with health insurance or who could afford to pay were carrying the cost of others who didn't pay. Hence, one aspirin cost $25.

Ironically, the situation we had prior to Obamacare was in essence a method of national healthcare with those who could, paying for those who couldn't.

I'm not saying one approach is better than the other. Just commenting.
 
#59 ·
This is the first year for me to file a tax return after having received Obamacare for one year. The government is charging a tax for the subsidy monies given to make the insurance "affordable". I'm retired, on SS, and the subsidy "assistance" I qualify for which makes the insurance affordable is a blessing but to tax those monies in the aftermath ?

I now understand why folks are forgoing the insurance and simply paying the $250 fine for not having Obamacare.

Pre-Obamacare, folks went to the emergency room if they couldn't afford healthcare insurance. The hospitals did their best to collect what they could from those patients, in a number of cases resorting to "writing off" the charges because the patient couldn't/wouldn't pay. That drove up the cost of hospital healthcare. Those with health insurance or who could afford to pay were carrying the cost of others who didn't pay. Hence, one aspirin cost $25.

Ironically, the situation we had prior to Obamacare was in essence a method of national healthcare with those who could, paying for those who couldn't.

I'm not saying one approach is better than the other. Just commenting.
Are you collecting social security but NOT age eligible for medicare? Unless you were a high earner your medicare payments should be 122.00 per year out of your ss check. If you are not yet age eligible you might want to look into medicaid. if you become medicaid eligible and reach 65 you may become duel eligible and have both medicare and medicaid at which time medicaid should pay for your 122.00 medicare costs.

failing all of that, you can tell all of your doctors, hospitals that the most you can afford is 5.00 per month and pay them that until your bills are either paid off or until you have paid for a year or two then ask that your bills be written off. i have never heard of a doctor or hospital that would not honor that request. if they dont it didnt hurt to try.
 
#32 ·
The pharmaceutical companies, doctors and especially the medical insurance companies are in cahoots to keep the price up.

For profit hospitals arranged by income level are common in the US, but unusual in the rest of the world.

As an example, I was in Bolivia and my wife went into anaphalactic shock after some bee stings. We checked into a hotel right after it happened. In my bad Spanish I told the desk Medico pronto. I guy showed up in our hotel room with a little leather bag like in the old days when I was a kid. He immediately saw the problem and called the hotel desk. They sent a kid to run to the Pharmacia and came to the room with a syringe. Problem solved in 15 minutes. It cost $20 for doctor and $3 for the drug that saved her. Say what you want about socialized medicine but that experience convinced me it is a good idea.
 
#37 ·
We used to pay $400 per month with $10 co-pay for well visits and a $1500 total deductible. It cost us less that $500 to have both babies delivered.
Now out .gov has reformed health care and I pay $80 per month, well visits are free but we have a $2500 deductible per person and $4500 family total. So its only costing about double. But then we take my son to the hospital and they discharge him "because we have private insurance" rather than admit him.
 
#39 ·
I don't buy the "Big Pharma is ripping us off" business. I used to work for a company that did a lot of work for a big pharma company, and their costs to bring a new drug to market are enormous. The discovery process alone is bad enough. They go through thousands of promising drugs every year, only to find that they don't work or that they have bad side effects. Then, when they do hit on one that works, they have to patent it before it's even ready to go to market so that some other company doesn't get a patent on it ahead of them. Then there are the clinical trials that run into $millions, and all the while the "shot clock" on their patent is running. And meanwhile, the FDA is all over them if they move a manufacturing machine a few feet to the left. If you want an example of FDA overreach, just remember when you couldn't get Excedrin for a few years.

Even if they get through the clinical trials and prove to the FDA that their drug does what they say it does and doesn't kill people in the process they have to market it. The generic companies are just biding their time, waiting till the patent expires, then they crank it out without having to pay a dime in development costs. The pharma company has a very narrow window of time in which to make a profit, most of which goes back into further research, covers the cost of keeping the lights on in the buildings and covering the lawsuits from the lawyers who are trolling for clients on late night TV.

Without "big pharma" continuing to search for new "wonder drugs" we'd still be treating everything with penicillin, sulfa powder and aspirin. But then you could always fall back on those if you think you're being ripped off on the price of drugs.
 
#79 ·
I don't buy the "Big Pharma is ripping us off" business. I used to work for a company that did a lot of work for a big pharma company, and their costs to bring a new drug to market are enormous.

yes... cause they have been known to add "marketing" into those figures

and not all new drugs have high costs..most are "me too" drugs



The discovery process alone is bad enough. They go through thousands of promising drugs every year, only to find that they don't work or that they have bad side effects.

most early stage research is funded by the taxpayer....most of the time by the time the drug cos starts to pony up their own money they know the drug will be "promising"....or should I say "profitable"




Then, when they do hit on one that works, they have to patent it before it's even ready to go to market so that some other company doesn't get a patent on it ahead of them. Then there are the clinical trials that run into $millions, and all the while the "shot clock" on their patent is running. And meanwhile, the FDA is all over them if they move a manufacturing machine a few feet to the left. If you want an example of FDA overreach, just remember when you couldn't get Excedrin for a few years.

REALLY?..........actually the gov't has came out and said that the big drug cos are too big for them to control now


Even if they get through the clinical trials and prove to the FDA that their drug does what they say it does and doesn't kill people in the process they have to market it. The generic companies are just biding their time, waiting till the patent expires, then they crank it out without having to pay a dime in development costs. The pharma company has a very narrow window of time in which to make a profit, most of which goes back into further research, covers the cost of keeping the lights on in the buildings and covering the lawsuits from the lawyers who are trolling for clients on late night TV.

Without "big pharma" continuing to search for new "wonder drugs" we'd still be treating everything with penicillin, sulfa powder and aspirin. But then you could always fall back on those if you think you're being ripped off on the price of drugs.
other than antibiotics could you please list these wonderdrugs?