I went through this thought process a few years ago. I do have an FAL, M1A (older Bush model), and a PTR91, but I wanted an AR in .308. Lots of choices, but I ended up going with a POF Revolution. Yes, it’s a gas piston. Yes, it has a few proprietary parts. Yes, I have spare parts. Yes, many parts are compatible with regular AR15 parts. Yes, the base weight was only 7.3 pounds. Yes, it’s far more accurate than I am with a guaranteed one-MOA. Yes, it’s been 100% reliable; zero issues with several hundred rounds.
It fit my requirements, I know the parts constraints, and with the lightest scope (Leupold 1-6 VX-6HD) and mount (LaRue, although Scalarworks now has a lighter mount), and a lightweight WML, I have the overall empty weight right at 9 pounds. Not a lightweight, but much lighter than any of my other .308 rifles, by far.
Even with the acceptable weight to actually “carry”, ammo weight sucks. It’s more of a patrol option around my immediate AO, not a long-range recce rifle.
7.62x51/.308WIN is still a very viable and effective cartridge and likely will be for decades to come. The .30-06 served for about 65 years (adopted in 1906 and served into the early 1970’s). The 7.62x51mm NATO cartridge was adopted in 1954 and is still serving today…it’s almost been 70’s years. Ironically, countries like Germany and Turkey have issued .308 rifles to Infantrymen (and they’re not DMRs). Finland and Sweden are also looking at developing a new line of NATO caliber weapons, one is an infantryman rifle in 7.62x51mm. Their use in GPMG’s are likely to also continue for more than a few decades and it’s still a pretty accurate cartridge inside 1000 meters; more than accurate enough for the vast majority of combat conditions.
ROCK6