Survivalist Forum banner

Your pet or you. Could YOU do it?

37K views 413 replies 189 participants last post by  2act  
#1 ·
I have being doing a lot of research as of late into historical situations where people were driven to great lengths to survive in urban environments.

Namely, the siege of Stalingrad and the city of Berlin during WW2, and Kosovo in the 90s.

In all situations, there are instances of desperation and situations where people were forced to their "family pets." I'm not talking about livestock, or even farm animals.

Think about it. You are stuck in or in a very close proximity to your home, and even the rats seem to have disappeared. You know you are starving.
It's a tough call, but in the last 100 years, thousands of people have been forced to make it.

I honestly don't know if I could. I haven't been desperate yet,and desperation changes things.
 
#9 ·
I will do it and much more if needed. After the all the dogs and cats are gone, animals with less legs are next. They way i see it if you cant put a bullet in the dog you for sure wont be able to put one in your wife or kids. If you think those things will be tough to do im betting it will be 1000 times harder to watch your kids starve to death right before your eyes, i doubt they will do it quietly.
 
#314 ·
Vivid Immagination



You know, I have not been on this forum long. But it's disturbing to see the amount of retarded, ignorant comments. If you could shoot your Dog then you have no values. You have no loyalty. Your Dog will be loyal to you and you should do the same.

I have been stock piling ammunition for a little while now. I have 2 AK's and 2 AR's and some other small munitions. I will be fine. My family will be fine. We shall live from the land if need be and protect what we regard high value. I won't eat my Dog, my wife, my kids or any other human being. Such things are Taboo. Are you really that stupid to do something like that? Or really I guess I should say are you really that stupid to even think something like that? People like you are what makes people like me prepare for what's coming in the end. I can assure you if I ever see anyone that holds the same values that you do.... They will for certain get a bullet in the head. I would shoot you and leave you lay. You are a weird Dude. You more than likely wouldn't last long anyway.... :thumb:
 
#10 ·
Nope. Never. I would die now in our 'utopia' to save my dog. That wouldn't change when the world ended.

I would end her suffering if need be (and most of us have to do that in one way or another at some point with with our furry friends), but that is as far as it goes. I trust her more than any human I have ever met and she deserves my respect for that.
 
#12 ·
I can't answer definitively, because I have never experienced anything close to starvation. Until one is actually put into that situation, the idea of what you would or would not do is only theoretical.
I can tell you this though. While my dogs are much loved, I have never been one to blur the lines between human and animal. In the end, no matter how much I love them, they are only animals, not human.
 
#13 ·
Depends, I have 4 dogs. I want at least 1 around to warn me, but if keeping them became an issue I'd have no choice. I will survive, it's all that matters if everything falls apart.

Now I won't be wanting to do something like that obviously, and I hope my decisions beforehand would better prepare me than having to eat my pets, but if I was locked in a room and had to pick me or my pet, I live.
 
#17 ·
I would never eat one of my pets. I would eat somebody else's pet, but not mine. I honestly would probably end up dying before my dog because I would split all my food with him. For those saying that if you can't put a bullet in your dog, you can't put a bullet in your wife or kids... wtf? We're talking about eating dogs, and you're throwing wives and children into the mix? Eat your own damn kids. If all other options were exhausted, I could shoot my pets or my family to spare them an even worse death should it be inevitable. ...but I wouldn't then eat them.
 
#100 ·
I agree with you a 100%. Hopefully we'll never get to that point but if we do I would rather shoot them out of their misery and then blow my head off and put an end to the Drama...Besides my dog, in my opinion, is worth a lot more than lots of people outthere. If we geet to the point where we are starving I would prefer to shoot some idiot and share him with my dog :)
 
#19 ·
My point of view is slightly different, how long would your pet honestly last you food wise, my dog would probably do two - three meals at most so that would give me maybe an extra week. Would it be worth just going through that short time having that on your conscious!

Then you have to think of the flea treatment, wormers, medications they take, would that make them totally unedible, would you be posioning yourself by eatting them.

Personally if you need to eat your pets then you've prepped wrong! A dog is too much of an assest to end up in the roasting dish!
 
#23 ·
My point of view is slightly different, how long would your pet honestly last you food wise, my dog would probably do two - three meals at most so that would give me maybe an extra week. Would it be worth just going through that short time having that on your conscious!
That's my take on it too. If you're so desperate as to eat your pets, those extra couple meals are not going to make a difference anyway. They'll only prolong the inevitable end a few more days.

As for whether I could do it. I don't know. My pets are family and I like them a WHOLE LOT more than I like people. It would be like eating a family member. I can eat some pretty weird stuff, but I doubt I could eat a pet. At that point, I'd probably just rather eat human flesh instead, though I could never murder someone to do it.
 
#22 ·
As was mentioned here already, a dog has many upside advantages - companionship, protection, and warmth when it gets cold. The purpose of preparing is not only for you and your family, but for the animals that you are taking care of.

Personally, I could never bring myself to filet an animal of mine. An animal of someone else that I am not attached to is another story.

I think that is why we bond with a pet. We take care of them and they in turn take care of us.
 
#25 ·
I stand corrected. My first post was way off. Now that a few have replied i now see the error in my previous post. I have realized that i wont be in such a desperate situation that would require me to eat our family dog. Thank yall for opening my eyes to a more realistic situation. From reading most of the replies i now realize that i will be surrounded by weak dying people and animals. Easy pickings for me, my dog and my family. Im thinking we will thrive under these conditions. I had no idea how many would offer them selves and their pets so easily. Makes me think i should reevaluate my prepping plans. I guess the old saying is correct, "only the strong will survive"..
 
#28 ·
Here's some more food for thought - no pun intended....

If you are in a situation that is so dire that there is nothing else to eat but your dog....

You are already dead.

Let's say you eat your dog, now what? You already stated that there was nothing left to eat. Do you cut off a finger or a foot to have something else to eat? Remember, there's NOTHING else to eat and you already ate your dog.
 
#27 ·
I've had my cats for 7 years, have had them since they were 6 weeks old. I love them but that being said i'd feel bad, heartbroken and I would try to keep them as long as I could but if I had to I would.
Now if it was a dog might be a different story, I don't know.
 
#30 ·
Well I believe like some other posters have said even if your starving how much longer are you going to be abel to keep going on that pet? Even a large one a week at the most? The OP said there are no other animals around and you pet is the only solution to not starving so what you eat you pet and in another week your going to starve anyway. Might as well shoot the pet and then yourself because in a scenario like that your dyign anyway. But not in a different situation like say you are traveling your staving you know for sure that in two or three days you can make it to a town where you can eat then yeah as much as I'd hate it I'd do it.