Survivalist Forum banner

Rock Island M200 Revolver - First Look

1 reading
13K views 45 replies 21 participants last post by  bilmac  
#1 ·
I almost bought a Rock Island M200 revolver (.38 Special) the other day, used for $320. Deal didn't go and I'm glad because my LGS put one on sale on Saturday for $219.99.

It is pretty much a Colt Detective knockoff.

I grabbed my keys and headed out the door. It came with a nice plastic box and was heavily coated with oil. The parkerized finish was a little off-putting at first but it cleaned up nicely.

Image


The single and double action were way better than I would have guessed they would be. Two complaints were easily fixed. It was hard to pick up the black front sight ramp. Yellow model paint solved that quickly.

The grips were kind of cheap feeling and there is an annoying seam. I tried buffing the seam down and it helped but the real fix was adding an inner tube grip sleeve. (remember to turn inside out for best results. 2.25 fit great.)

Off to the range. All worked as expected. I had already dry fired (about 500 times) and lubed. It is a good shooter IMHO, at least my copy is.

While not +P rated I am confident that it could get the job done if required.

I would give it a 4 1/2 out of 5 for an inexpensive revolver.
 

Attachments

#2 ·
Thanks for the review.

I have one of their 1911s and it is an entirely serviceable pistol that I have been very happy with.
 
#4 ·
Thanks for the review. I have some RIA 1911s that seem of good quality, and one of their shotguns, a Marine Magnum 12 ga.

I will comment that in my only interaction with their customer service, I was very impressed. The shotgun had a minor issue and they paid round trip shipping and fixed it for free and promptly.

RIA is good to go in my book.
 
#6 ·
I can second the great customer service from RIA. My 1911 had a minor issue and they took better care of me over an inexpensive pistol than Kimber did for one that cost 3 times as much and had a BIGGER issue.

In fact the Kimber should have been replaced as defective but after two trips back for warranty they decided a frame with non-parallel rails met their QC specs.
 
#10 ·
Anyway, back to the topic at hand.
Day two at the range. The M200 is starting to really break in and I am shooting it better today than yesterday (yesterday was not bad but today was pretty darn good.)

I took one of my adult sons with me. He's a lefty and also did very well with it.

One thing I have noticed is that the barrel seems to get hotter than other revolvers I own. I understand that the barrel is two piece with an inner sleeve.

I also noticed a very slight bit of shaving when shooting 158 grain rounds. Might be more of an ammo issue than a firearm issue.

Still give it a 4.5 out of 5 for an inexpensive revolver.
 
#16 ·
Thanks for the review. I have seen those locally for under $250.00 new in the 4" and 2" barrel lengths. For those prices, I have considered picking up one of each. there is a lot of utility in a $250.00 2" .38, the fact it has 6 shots is just a bonus.

I am out of my dedicated "truck" or car gun stage of life, but it would seem made for that, or a tackle box, hand out, etc.
 
#17 ·
I'm really surprised that no one else seems to have one of these. I have been shooting this several times a week, mostly because I have a ton of components for .38 Special, but also because I am really pleased with how well it shoots.

The cylinder release was just a bit tight when it was new but now it is like glass, very easy to use but crisp and exact.

I understand that the factory grips will not allow for a speed loader but I have been practicing with speed strips and have regained some of my revolver skills from my early years on the job.

I have been doing three shot, instinctive shooting drills and it is a very natural pointer.
 
#19 ·
I'm really surprised that no one else seems to have one of these. I have been shooting this several times a week, mostly because I have a ton of components for .38 Special, but also because I am really pleased with how well it shoots.

The cylinder release was just a bit tight when it was new but now it is like glass, very easy to use but crisp and exact.

I understand that the factory grips will not allow for a speed loader but I have been practicing with speed strips and have regained some of my revolver skills from my early years on the job.

I have been doing three shot, instinctive shooting drills and it is a very natural pointer.
By the time these came on the market I had already filled my revolver dance card with a Ruger GP100 4", SW629 6" and SW442. I did recently add a SW69 4" because I wanted a light weight 44Mag for around the property.

Glad it's turning into a decent revolver for you and I would definitely consider it if I needed to add to my stash.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sarge912
#18 ·
You really dont see them much around here, which is kind of surprising, as the cheaper guns seem to be a big part of the market and tend to go quick here. I think Ive seen one in the past 4 or 5 years, and it wasnt as cheap as the one you got.

If I didnt already have a bunch of S&W's of similar ilk, and was short on money, Id probably try one. At least they seem to be gaining a better rep than things like Taurus and a couple of others.
 
#24 ·
It sounds like where you are regionally has a big difference in prices. Around here, a beat up S&W police trade in, or beat up Smiths in general, go for a good bit more than $400 anymore, and any that are in good shape, are in the $600+ range. And that was prior to the current craziness.

Not saying you cant do better in private sales, but in any of the shops, they are getting salty.
 
#26 ·
I have an M200 and M206. I picked them up on a couple of local sales from guys needing money. I bought them for ~$165-175 each. They beat a highpoint in concealability and function while costing about the same. I haven't had a chance to do much with them other than get them cleaned up. I got sidetracked on finding a hunting rifle and holsters for other stuff.

The revolver market is slim here. Usually only $600 used Ruger SP101s and higher priced revolvers getting closer to $1000. If any good deal shows up on an older S&W Model 10 or equivalent revolvers, you have to pounce; or more than likely anymore, it's a scammer.
 
#29 ·
Interesting trip to my local LGS.
I saw an M200 in the case so one must have come in as they had run out.
The counter guy was showing it to me, while telling me that this was the only one that came in and they had just put it in the case before I got there.

When I picked it up it seemed a bit off with closer exam revealing that the barrel was canted, I pointed it out to the counter guy who looked skeptical at first but when he looked down the sights he quickly agreed.

He called the manager over who also saw the problem so they pulled it. I could have reserved the next one in but decided to pass.

The sale is until the end of the month so, who knows? There may still be another one in my future.

It wasn't a wasted trip, I was able to score 1000 CCI small magnum pistol primers (550's)
and 1000 large rifle primers (200) for only $32.00 each. The price tag showed $42 each brick but they rang up at the old price. Score!

Primers are selling way above that on Armslist these days, up to $100+ a brick with Small pistol being the one most sought after.

Also, the powder aisle was almost fully stocked. Maybe a sign that things are slowing down.
 
#30 ·
I bought one used 4 years ago For 180 bucks. It’s pretty good. My only complaint is that after a hundred rounds or so it started getting a little Stuck in double action. After cleaning it real quick h it was back to shooting again.

It’s accurate, looks nice, and feels good in hand.

I gave mine to my mother to keep in her house, mainly because my step fathers only gun is a .44 magnum and she is an old woman who could not handle his revolver...... but .38sp is light enough for anyone.
 
#35 ·
I found one of these semi-locally finally for 10 bucks more than you paid. I have had an eye out since you started this thread. I ended up leaving the store with a different purchase but I plan to return as soon as funds allow to pick one up. Thanks for the review and continued comments.
 
#41 ·
I was really fortunate with my first one. I picked up a second one recently and had to return it for repair, right out of the box.
They ended up sending me a replacement as they said it could not be repaired.
The new one works but not anywhere near as accurate as my first one. :(