Survivalist Forum banner
1 - 5 of 5 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
228 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Has anyone tried growing a lemon tree from seed? If you have, how well did it work? I am going to try to grow one and want to know how hard it is. I found a few good sites that talk about it, but none of them is from "first hand" knowledge.

Also if you have grown if you have tips I'll take those too.
 

· Banned
Joined
·
17,930 Posts
I grew both a lemon and an orange from seed. It takes between 8 and 10 years to get fruit. I got lucky and the fruit on both were good. The lemon was a Lisbon lemon from the grocery store and it came pretty much true to type except the ends weren't nearly as pointy, more like just little nubs, but the flavor was good. The orange was from a grocery store orange, unknown type, medium thick skin. The orange I got was thin skinned, and quite tight on the fruit and hard to peel. The skin was also blotchy and ugly, but the flesh inside was extremely good--a good orange flavor, very sweet, juicy, and not very acidic. Both trees were vigorous on their own roots in the ground. I moved from that house and don't know anymore about them. They fruited for me for about five years before we moved.

From what I understand, most citrus you only have a 50/50 chance of getting good tasting fruit from seeds, so I guess I got lucky. Also most citrus are grafted on trifoliate orange rootstock to prevent them from dying from soil borne diseases. So if you grow citrus from seeds and plant them in the ground, they may or may not die from disease.
 

· Weed 'em and reap
Joined
·
32,955 Posts
Has anyone tried growing a lemon tree from seed? If you have, how well did it work? I am going to try to grow one and want to know how hard it is. I found a few good sites that talk about it, but none of them is from "first hand" knowledge.

Also if you have grown if you have tips I'll take those too.
Growing from seed is a crap shoot. Think of rolling thousands of dice. Each die controls one aspect of one trait. In order to get a tree as good as the original, which fruits early and heavily, makes good fruit, is disease resistant, etc., is a very rare occurance. In fact, the commercial citrus growers don't even propagate trees with all of these traits; they use scions with early, heavy, good fruit, and rootstocks with disease resistance, and vigor.

If you want to grow good trees from seed, it is a numbers game. And even then, many new developments are the result of mutations, genetic defects, and other quirks. As such, even chance seedlings are rare improvements. You will need to grow literally thousands, if not more, from seed, to get trees as good as their progenitors. And then, you will have to test scions from your seedling trees on an early maturing rootstock.

Citrus, unlike most self-fertile fruits, are notorious for not being true to seed. They are so far developed from their natural state, which produces insipid fruit, that they are more likely to revert than to make good fruit. But, they will eventually bear fruit, however infrequently that may be, and, at the very least, the fruit will be good for zest.
 
1 - 5 of 5 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top