I see some holes in your logic, but that's ok. Everybody's entitled to their own opinion.
Your original post comes off as condescending and aloof. Maybe try toning it down a bit, if you want to better prove your point, would be my gentle suggestion.
To say that a Bic lighter is always superior to a ferro rod is a bit ridiculous. It's true, however, that both have their strengths and weaknesses.
Ferro rods have no moving parts to seize up or break. They never run out of fuel. They work immediately, no matter how long they've been exposed to moisture or submersion. The ferro rod doesn't require the fine motor skills that a Bic would, if you're in the beginning-to-advanced stages of hypothermia...it relies on larger muscle groups/movements which would be easier for a person in a life-or-death, need-a fire-right-now situation.
And most importantly... They teach the critical skill of proper fire preparation and building before ever making the first spark. Skipping the "tinder stage" of proper fire building is dangerous and perhaps foolish. You might get away with it sometimes using a Bic, but sooner or later it'll come back and bite you square in the ass...hopefully not at a bad time.
Before you try to flame me, I want you to realize I'm no rookie. I've been practicing the art of survival/bushcraft for well over 25 years now. My skills are pretty well honed, but I would never say there's no room for improvement...that would be foolish. I have also been a smoker for over 20 years, and carry a Bic AND a ferro rod on my person, daily.
The Bic is back-up only, IMO. I would never count on it as a critical piece of fire starting gear, in a true survival situation.
Your original post comes off as condescending and aloof. Maybe try toning it down a bit, if you want to better prove your point, would be my gentle suggestion.
To say that a Bic lighter is always superior to a ferro rod is a bit ridiculous. It's true, however, that both have their strengths and weaknesses.
Ferro rods have no moving parts to seize up or break. They never run out of fuel. They work immediately, no matter how long they've been exposed to moisture or submersion. The ferro rod doesn't require the fine motor skills that a Bic would, if you're in the beginning-to-advanced stages of hypothermia...it relies on larger muscle groups/movements which would be easier for a person in a life-or-death, need-a fire-right-now situation.
And most importantly... They teach the critical skill of proper fire preparation and building before ever making the first spark. Skipping the "tinder stage" of proper fire building is dangerous and perhaps foolish. You might get away with it sometimes using a Bic, but sooner or later it'll come back and bite you square in the ass...hopefully not at a bad time.
Before you try to flame me, I want you to realize I'm no rookie. I've been practicing the art of survival/bushcraft for well over 25 years now. My skills are pretty well honed, but I would never say there's no room for improvement...that would be foolish. I have also been a smoker for over 20 years, and carry a Bic AND a ferro rod on my person, daily.
The Bic is back-up only, IMO. I would never count on it as a critical piece of fire starting gear, in a true survival situation.