kev... the question isnt really if you are sold on 300 blackout, the question is if you are vested in reloading... if the answer is yes, then go for the 300, if the answer is no, you might want to stick with what you got.
Okay...why? Ammo is $0.60 a round. What centerfire rifle ammo is cheaper? 5.56, and some of the Russian calibers, basically. Would you advise anyone to avoid .30-06, .308, etc. if they did not reload? I never understood this stance.
i got into 300 blk about 4-5 months ago... got a YHM fluted 16" bbl at a nice price, but my main deciding factor was that i have .223 brass stock and could convert plenty at a low price. i also have a good stock of H110 and W296 powder since i already reloaded for 30 carbine, 357 mag and 44 mag. Plus i had an extra upper reciever laying around to put the bbl on, so the 'stars aligned' so to speak.
I do enjoy the round, its easy to reload for, and lehigh defense makes some absolutely fantastic projectiles (controlled chaos, 110 gr) that i also use for hot .308 hunting loads out of my ruger gunsight. Lehigh has some brains and know-how, also. The AR platform is new to them, but they are learning it rapidly, and evolving nicely. Otherwise, they are a seriously evolved operation. Moreover, they are VERY responsive to customer input. I have enjoyed my interaction with them.
300 blk is flexible in that it can accept a very wide array of projectile weights in .308, but again this primarily points to feasibility to a reloader. if you plan on only purchasing new factory, it might not be worth the capital cost if you have other priorities right now. Sure it is. Just the same as any other weapon. I don't reload and am quite happy.
personally i dont think it does much on the external ballistic front any better then the 7.62x39, but i own 2 of those already, and i reload for .308, 30-06 and 30 carbine already so i figured, why not, and i wasnt really looking at it from a pragmatic standpoint. that being said, it is now sitting next to my night stand with a 60 round surefire mag, a surefire x300hd and a aimpoint compm4 on it... the controlled chaos rounds that i loaded in there dont over penetrate through household barriers and are absolutely devastating in flesh... so thats what i am rolling with in the house (outside of pistols). that isnt to say i couldnt load those 110 grain rounds in my 30 carbine, but i would have to do some custom load work and adjust the OAL...
How has that 60 round mag done? I personally would not run one, and I am a huge SureFire fan. I talked with...a few people...about it before I came to that conclusion. As to the 300BLK, no, you're absolutely right, it's a 7.62x39 in different clothing, as far as I'm concerned---not that that's a bad thing!
i have loaded about 600 rounds or it (both match and controlled chaos projectiles), and i have bought only about 400 PNW 125 grain a-max rounds, which i spent just over $1 per round on... so i only have about 1100 rounds on hand for 300 blk which pales in comparison to every other stock of caliber i have to include 6.8 SPC, so know its not for particularily high volume shooting. Yes it is. Why wouldn't it be? I have thousands of rounds of the stuff. Priorities and preferences...that's all. i think i was reloading the match rounds for about 40-45 cents per round.